You can tell a lot about someone by the costume they reach for every October. The vampire who lives for candlelight. The witch who can't resist mixing a new potion. The werewolf who gets a little wild when the moon is full.
At AfterTouch Toys, we think your costume is a pretty good clue to what you'd enjoy after the party, too. So we've matched six classic Halloween characters with the best Halloween sex toys for their personality. Find yours, find your partner's, and plan a night that's all treat.
Not sure which one you are? Read all six. Most of us are a little bit of everyone.
1.The Vampire: Slow, Sensual and Made for Candlelight
You're all about the build-up. Lingering looks, soft lighting and a little drama. For you, the best part of the night is taking your time. Your treat: the Love to Love Light My Fire Drip Candle. Unlike an ordinary candle, it melts into a warm, low-temperature wax made for dripping onto skin, so every slow drip feels as dramatic as it looks. Pair it with a plush blindfold and let anticipation do the rest. Vampire tip: Dim every light in the room and use the candle as your only glow.
2. The Witch: Curious, Playful and Always Experimenting
You love a little magic and you're never afraid to try something new. Your bedside drawer looks like a potion shelf, and you like it that way. Your treat: The Hot & Cold massager. It warms up or cools down and vibrates at the same time, so you can mix the two for a spell of temperature play you won't forget. Add a few drops of JO H2O Warming lube for an extra tingle. Stock up on more potions in our warming lubes collection.
3. The Werewolf: Wild, Primal and Ruled by the Full Moon
You're sweet most of the month, then something takes over. You like it a little rougher, a little louder, and a lot more playful. Your treat: the Tailz Midnight Fox Tail Plug. A smooth glass plug topped with a long, gleaming black faux-fur tail turns any costume into the real thing, and the fun doesn't stop when the costume comes off. New to tail plugs? Our guide to the best butt plugs in 2026 covers sizes, materials and tail styles for beginners.
4. The Ghost: Mysterious, Teasing and Hard to Pin Down
You're there, then you're not. You love a secret, a whisper across a crowded room, and keeping your partner guessing all night long. Your treat: the Lovense Lush 4. Wear it under your costume and hand your partner the app. Nobody at the party will know why you keep smiling. That's the most haunting kind of fun. Find more invisible mischief in our remote control vibrators.
5. The Mummy: Wrapped Up and Ready to Surrender
Ordinary isn't in your vocabulary. You love fantasy, you love a story, and you're the first to try something nobody else would. Your treat: the Monstropus Tentacled Monster Silicone Dildo. Dual rows of octopus-style suckers and a marbled green, yellow and blue finish make every one unique. It's pure deep-sea fantasy, made for the most adventurous creature in the room.
6. Bonus: The Matching Couples Costume
You planned your costumes together, so why not plan the after-party together too? Couples who dress as a duo usually love sharing the fun just as much. Your treat: the Pleasure Pivot App-Enabled Couples Toy, made for two and controlled from your phone. Not sure where to start? Roll the Dirty Dice Foreplay Game and let chance decide your first move.
Keep the Night Spooky, Not Scary
-
Talk about it first. Agree on boundaries and a safe word before any wax, restraint or role-play.
-
Test the wax. Drip a little on your own forearm first, and hold the candle higher for a cooler drip.
-
Use the right lube. Choose water-based lube with silicone toys.
-
Clean up after. Wash toys before and after every use.
Your Treats, Delivered Discreetly
Every AfterTouch Toys order ships across Canada in plain, unbranded packaging, so the only surprise is the one you planned. Order early to have everything in hand before October 31st. So, which character are you this year? Whichever costume you choose, make sure the night ends with a treat.
Happy Halloween from AfterTouch Toys.